Zack -  Mr. GenXer

Do you think a smart enough person can make people as a whole believe anything?

11

11 Answers

Ancient Hippy Profile
Ancient Hippy answered

It's possible, just ask Orson Wells:


Didge Doo Profile
Didge Doo answered

There's a truism that you can fool all of the people some of the time, some of the people all of the time, but you can't fool all of the people all of the time.

But you can fool enough people enough of the time!

Consider the demagogues who have persuaded populations to vote for them; consider successful salespeople who will tell any lie to get their commission; consider infamous felons like Bernie Madoff who were so convincing they conned even smart investors out of their money; consider the plethora of pyramid schemes that still attract suckers; consider people like L. Ron Hubbard who founded phoney religions; consider the Republican nominee for the November election.


13 People thanked the writer.
Ancient One
Ancient One commented
Very true. Time and time again.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
We learn slowly, Ancient. Unfortunately some folk don't seem to learn at all.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
Think about it Tiger. You're smarter than that.
But I'll certainly agree that both candidates are pretty uninspiring this year.
Kvothe Savien Profile
Kvothe Savien answered

No...because there is always someone that is smarter.

Call me Z Profile
Call me Z answered

The power of persuasion is more about charisma than intelligence. Persistently repeat the most fanciful lie, do it with conviction; engage others to corroborate it, present elaborate symbology and throw shade on (or --Gasp!-- invent a crime for) opposing views, and you can control masses of people. 

Facts are not necessary, in fact, they often are the enemy; only the illusion of intelligence is necessary. I'm sure we all could cite numerous examples. 

12 People thanked the writer.
Ancient One
Ancient One commented
Yes, if you tel a lie enough times it becomes the truth. Look at our world today. In a little over 15 - 20 years actions and activities we opposed as a people and as a nation have now become common place,
Virginia Lou
Virginia Lou commented
Zee That is beautifully stated
Matt Radiance Profile
Matt Radiance answered

Of course not. Nobody can make "everyone" to believe in one united factor. Look at history, look at now, "belief" is the most varied title within people. Everyone believing differently.

But charisma is the key. You can impact thousands or millions but yet not "all" after all, with the right charisma, communication skill and confidence you can make an army on your own. People can be impressed easily at some point. You can check Davidians. Their history will inform you how this can work.

Thrice Gotcha Profile
Thrice Gotcha answered

no certainly not if that was the case everyone would share the same beliefs people are too complex and unique to have a set belief system everyone is going to believe in what they want too

PJ Stein Profile
PJ Stein answered

No. If you look at people throughout history who supposedly swayed the masses, it wasn't their wisdom that did it. It was the fear of what would happen if they didn't follow.

DDX Project Profile
DDX Project answered

Bill O'Riely fans, Alex Jones fans, Donald Trump fans, Glenn Beck fans, etc... Etc.

I always get the notion that Bill O'riely and some of these guys don't even believe the majority of the things they say. But they're good at it, and it makes them feel powerful. And weak underdeveloped minds seem to gobble the sensationalize monologues like chicken feed. I mean, what's there to develop a person's mind when you're secluded from the majority of civilization in your small rural town or village that's 99% white and in the middle of nowhere? When your knowledge of Chinese food is "beef and broccoli" and anyone who wears a turban to you is a "Muslim"?

And if I am actually wrong, and these people aren't actually weak and dumb. Then why are they having such a hard time under Obama's presidency? Why are they losing their jobs to illegals who can't even speak English or enjoyed all the benefits of being born in the United States of America? Meanwhile people who have better things to do with their time then watch or listen to these folks are prospering?

5 People thanked the writer.
DDX Project
DDX Project commented
That's just my observation. I'm not saying all people are a certain way. But when you look at the fan base, there are many telling signs on what kind of people are attracted to such personalities.
KB Baldwin
KB Baldwin commented
Well, I think DDX is close to the truth. And blaming it on this administration is weak. The last administration wasn't all that good at jobs either, except for those connected to the military.
DDX Project
DDX Project commented
So the Obama administration sent assassins to kill them or something? Otherwise I don't see how Obama would be able to take someone's life.
Anonymous Profile
Anonymous answered

You don't have to be smart to persuade though. Religion's proved that.

4 People thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
But it's difficult to persuade anybody of anything if you post anonymously.
Ancient One
Ancient One commented
You have that right.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
It's interesting, Ancient, that when you commented my notification came up with the name of the poster rather than anonymous. This will probably show his name in your notifications. Anonymity is apparently very limited.

Answer Question

Anonymous