Pepper pot

I watched a program the other night about a lady who had a son with Down's syndrome. She was looking at the effects that screening has on the Down's population, and whether termination will lead to their demise? Last year 100% of Polish women with a positive screening for Down's, terminated. With the screening process now able to find other genetic defects how long will it be before other conditions are seen as unfavourable, take for example asthma or big noses, and cause people to abort? What happens when it is one of us that will be seen as unfavourable and terminated? Where is genetics and society's priorities leading us, bearing in mind science has no morality, just answers?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s8audGmlFc4

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-37500189

4

4 Answers

PJ Stein Profile
PJ Stein answered

I have to wonder how many of those Polish women were talked into terminating? I know in the US, many people are told they are having a Down's child, but opt to keep it. As we have learned over the years, Down's is not as crippling as it was once thought to be. They are productive people, and some own their own business. They may take a little longer to learn, but they do learn. And often they are some of the friendliest and happiest people. At least that has been my experience. 

And to say science has no morality I think is a stretch. The scientist are part of a society and that is where the morality comes from.

9 People thanked the writer.
Pepper pot
Pepper pot commented
I agree about people with Down's being productive members of society, and very happy and loving people. However, the abortion rate when given a positive Down's test is high in both America and England. Science does not have morality, it cannot have morality in of itself, only answers, morality comes in when people act on those answers as you say. We live in a society where it is acceptable to terminate the majority of pregnancies because that foetus will grow into a person with Down's syndrome, and people can choose whether they want a child with Down's syndrome. This program then brought up the idea that where does that stop, will society one day deem it acceptable to abort a foetus that has a condition that any one of us could suffer with and I think it is a wake up call. It was extremely thought provoking and I thought I'd add it here. Thanks for your input Gator.
Maurice Korvo Profile
Maurice Korvo answered

After seeing that, do you dare send in your DNA sample for someone to check it out and send you the results.  How long before DNA sample is taken from every child born to check for defects?

Tom  Jackson Profile
Tom Jackson answered

Same with scientific capabilities of the nuclear age.

What to do with the discoveries is up to us humans.

Genetics is science.

Society's priorities are ultimately human priorities---what will we accept?

Virginia Lou Profile
Virginia Lou answered

Dear Pepper Pot,

Your links, more and more I am pleased to see this kind of advocacy...            I notice the woman on the video, she refused the screening for G3 trisomy because she was actually fearful of physicians pressuring her.

* * *

Here is an idea I am pondering at present, from other questions on Blurt:

Before we undertake eugenics programs like this one, let's set some benchmarks. That when we have proven our wisdom by, for instance, finding our way to world peace and eliminating hunger, then let's go ahead and consider eugenics. (And I read it would take just 13 days of suspending military spending to wipe out world hunger.)

And btw, yours is one of those Blurt postings that I find just very helpful for developing my own perspective...

1 Person thanked the writer.
Virginia Lou
Virginia Lou commented
I took this from the BBC link:

"Having Olly in my life has changed me and my family for the better. He has slightly worse impulse control but that means that it's very funny because he's often saying exactly what everybody's thinking but is too shy to say.

"He's also incredibly caring. He's the only one of my three kids who every single day will ask me how my day was. He's really kind. He's really focused on other people. He's really gifted emotionally. He'll notice if people are upset when I won't."
Pepper pot
Pepper pot commented
I enjoyed your answers Virginia, thank you

Answer Question

Anonymous