Home Debates An American Or British Life Has More Value Than That Of An Iraqi Or...
An American Or British Life Has More Value Than That Of An Iraqi Or Afghan. Even When The Victims Are Non Combatants.
For
During The Northern Ireland Conflict Even The Media Admitted That A Single English Life Lost In Northern Ireland Was Of Greater News Value Than That Of A Person Born In The North Of Ireland. The Hierarchy Was Noted As Follows. Starting With The Most Important Ie, The Englishman Then The Scot Then The Welsh Then The Northern Irish Protestant And Least Of All The Northern Irish Catholic. Although Northern Ireland Was A Supposedly Equal Part Of Britishness, The Media Openly Admitted That It Was An Unfortunate Fact Of Life That This Hierarchy Existed. Is This True Of Iraq.
by Padraig Padraig
 16 Apr 2008 04:24  
Against
 The value of the people's lives were only just determined by any of you by the source of information... Before you were told by this debate or the media or how ever you found out the people died.... You did not care, because you did not know.. So for the sake of argument the British were more important to each and every person who received the information until other information was given to them to let them know the British weren't the only ones. So in that aspect yes sometimes some people are more important than others...only because you don't know any better and end up caring only about what you've been let known
 18 Apr 2008 19:56
by Kmo Kmo
 True. According to the liberal news media () us westerners are somehow more valued than the native Iraqis or Afghans. That's the truth about objectivity in journalism: The only objective is advertising revenue.
 16 Apr 2008 11:27
by Guest Guest
 It is true. People walk against what god has teached and just Pushes of the concept of equality.
 31 Aug 2008 11:26
by Farwa Farwa
 If you break us down to our basic elements minus gold teth or artificial hips and what have you a human body is only worth about $16.00 on the open commodities market we are mostly as you know carbon and water neither are tradeing that well right now
 31 May 2008 14:20
by Ak907 Ak907
 Everybody is created equal!Everybody's life is valued the same!
 05 May 2008 15:03
by Luverboy Luverboy
 "An American Or British Life Has More Value Than That Of An Iraqi Or Afghan. Even When The Victims Are Non Combatants." - depends on how you look at it. Realistically, an American or British may think that their race is superior. An Iraqi or Afghan may think that their race is superior. At media value, an American or British casualty in war [or in anything, really] has more 'viewer value' than an Afghan or an Iraqi - probably because casualties have become normal, and nobody could care less. In the eyes of God, though, none is better or worse. We're all human, all sinners, and all Saved. Of course, if you're not Christian, your viewpoint may be different, but if your stand is the same is saying that all humans are people, then it shouldn't matter - race shouldn't matter, or nationality. WHATEVER. What should matter is how our lives were lived, not where we lived our lives. Wonderful topic.
 02 May 2008 19:01
by Ibelieve Ibelieve
 Phew this is one of those debate topics that takes your breath away when you first read it. To think anyone ever came out with a statement like that!

There is no way to estimate the value of a human being.

And people who try do so are just plain worthless ;)

That's not as facetious as it first looks - people who judge and condemn others are usually indulging in a bit of shadow projection, aren't they.
 19 Apr 2008 16:41
by Zwanger Zwanger
 Nationality does not matter, it is the value of the person that counts!
 16 Apr 2008 18:07
by Samiamiam Samiamiam
 The main word we should be looking at is NEWS value. That just depends on who is writing or reading it. Every soul has the same value.
 16 Apr 2008 16:12
by Barbe45 Barbe45
 All life is precious to God. I do not believe that Nationality diminishes a persons value.
 16 Apr 2008 13:57
by Pencil Pencil
 No one persons life is more important than anothers, its how you live your life that is important. Regarding the Media - its horses for courses, in the middle east the reporting of Iraqi lives lost to or because of the allied invader are reported more as that it what gets a more reactive response and sells the papers over there. Same as in the NI conflict, in Ireland and the catholic press (and to a certain extent the American press to get sympathy) it was the loss of catholic lives for the cause that were most reported, the death of a British soldier was celebrated.
 16 Apr 2008 13:27
by Rostdu Rostdu
 I guess that depends on who you ask.
 16 Apr 2008 10:36
by Billzbub Billzbub
 I personal find the statement offensive, but the explanation all too true. It is a shame that the news services have come down to this, and that they control the information that we have available. I can't place a value on people so that I may put them at different levels. This one more valued than that one who is more valued than that. It is just hard to say what can be done to make change when there is so much that needs to change.
 02 Sep 2008 02:14
by Jeremym Jeremym
 We all created equal. But in war it better them than us, but we should value innocent civilians.
 30 Jul 2008 06:51
by Panson Panson
 All i can say is human life shouldn't be evaluated in terms of their value on news channels or papers.
Media should stop evaluating such in-human things & should provide coverage on more people in trouble worldwide this will earn them equally high revenue.
 14 May 2008 23:58
by Life Life
People Need To Spend Less Time Worrying About What Others Do 'Wrong'.
When Obama Gets Into Office We Will Get Into A Third World War.
Democrats And Independence Voters Can Be Good Christians
Do You Think 9/11 Should Become A National Holiday ?
What Are The Advantages And Disadvantages Of 21th Century?
Must The American Flag Have A Spot Light On It At Night?
What Is Rose Red?
Should History Be Taught In Schools?
Which Are The New Seven Wonders Of The World?
 
 

Ask a Question via Twitter

Send a question to @askblurtit and we will publish it online and send you a reply everytime you receive an answer.

Blurtit Store

Get T-shirts, hoodies, caps and more at the Blurtit store

Blurtit International