Home Debates Everybody Deserves To Afford Health Care. However, Implementing Universal...
Everybody Deserves To Afford Health Care. However, Implementing Universal Health Care In The USA Would Result In An Economic Tragedy Of The Commons.
For
Universal Health Care Is Health Care Coverage Which Is Extended To All Citizens, And Sometimes Permanent Residents, Of A Governmental Region. Universal Health Care Programs Vary Widely In Their Structure And Funding Mechanisms, Particularly The Degree To Which They Are Publicly Funded. Typically, Most Health Care Costs Are Met By The Population Via Compulsory Health Insurance Or Taxation, Or A Combination Of Both. Implementing This Type Of Program In The USA Would Result In An Economic Tragedy Of The Commons. That Is, Free Access And Unrestricted Demand For A Finite Resource Would Ultimately Structurally Doom The Resource Through Over-exploitation.
by Jungle_jim Jungle_jim
 16 Aug 2008 12:25  
Against
 I agree and the government needs to set a plan into action.
 20 Aug 2008 17:21
by Bwtsrl Bwtsrl
 I think you pose a pretty convincing argument.
 16 Aug 2008 14:25
by Pencil Pencil
 Universal health care would not cause an economic tragedy. Several countries offer universal health care, and those countries have the best overall health, longest life expectancies, and lowest infant mortality rates.

Yes, the money for universal health care has to come from somewhere, but those countries that have it don't have economic hardships because of it.

So the question becomes "how can we afford it" or where can we get the money? I think the easiest and fairest way is to 1) a sin tax on alcohol and tobacco, maybe even other vices such as pornographic materials, some kind of tax structure at casinos and lotteries, etc. Or 2) increasing sales tax by 3%. I don't think that is very much--if you spend $200 a week, that is $6 you'd be paying towards universal coverage, or $24 a month. Cheaper than most insurance premiums. And if hospitals and clinics know they are only going to get paid so much for services, it prevents them from overcharging and continuing to escalate prices.

Also, keep in mind that universal coverage would only cover medically necessary care. If you wanted a mole removed that wasn't causing you any problems, you'd still have to pay for it. If you wanted tests that a doctor sees no reason for, you would still be required to pay for them.

As long as we follow the model set forth by other countries, and everyone puts into it, it will work fine.
 16 Aug 2008 14:06
by Dragon72 Dragon72
 Nobody deserves to afford anything.
 18 Aug 2008 01:58
by Guest Guest
Illegal Immigrants Should Not Receive Free Healthcare.
Should We Smoke Or Not Smoke
A Patient Who Signs A "Do Not Resusitate" Order Is Asking For Passive Suicide.
Are Natural Supplements The Way To Go?
Smokers Are Being Treated Like Criminals
Should Psychiatrist Mostly Treat Mentally Ill People With Drugs?
Some Student Take Up Smoking, What Effects Can This Have On Their Lives, And Can They Do To Give Up Smoking...
There Should Be A Statute Passed Whereby Consumers Can Ask For And Evaluate A Doctor's Educational And...
Smoking Should Not Appear In Movies.
California Needs To Have The Budget Signed.
If US Healthcare Insurers Were Incented To Compete On Delivering Better Care, Rather Than Competing On...
Universal Health Care Works!
Is Self Medication Good?
Meditation Is Better Than Medication For Leading A Healthy Life.
Smoking Should Be Banned From Homes Containing Children Under The Age Of 18
 
 

Ask a Question via Twitter

Send a question to @askblurtit and we will publish it online and send you a reply everytime you receive an answer.

Blurtit Store

Get T-shirts, hoodies, caps and more at the Blurtit store

Blurtit International