Home Debates Is Alcoholism Really A Disease ?
Is Alcoholism Really A Disease ?
For
Always Considered It An Addiction But, Health Authorities Have Declared It A Disease--AGREE?----DISAGREE ?
by Whhandyman Whhandyman
 01 Oct 2007 19:19  
Against
 I also grew up believing alcoholism was a "condition" with symptoms of addiction, rather than a disease. However, I agree now that it constitutes a disease, one with both psychological and physical origins, and with symptoms that include addiction, which manifests in physical and psychological symptoms and can cause secondary diseases of vital organs due to ethanol ingestion.

I think some confusion over the words "disease" and "addiction" occur because historically, we were conditioned to think of disease only in physical terms, that being the extent of our knowledge and technology... And addiction was interpreted as the condition rather than the symptom of alcoholism. This is a common and only recently changing mindset, in that now through technology and science we have begun to understand conditions such as schizophrenia and obsessive-compulsive disorder, and bi-polar depressive syndrome as diseases also which have organic and physcial disease links. Alcoholism has origins in both.

Anyway, with regard to alcoholism, the disease:
First, many who have the disease are predisposed by a specific gene which was identified positively in the late 1980's. The gene link works to foster an addiction (the outward symptoms of disease) in those who possess it when exposed to alcohol consumption.

2) In those who are not pre-disposed by the gene, alcohol works to change the brain and body chemistry and biologic pre-disposition to foster/create a physcial need for/dependency upon alcohol, and also changes the brain and body chemistry to create a specific reaction to alcohol of the subject over time with consumption. This has essentially the effect of creating the same physical syndrome as if one had been born with the gene. Again, the outward manifestation includes addictive behavior, as both brain and body chemsitry are altered to a different response than someone without the disease. Portions of the brain are modified (permanently) to react and metabolize alcohol in the system. The condition, like all diseases, is irreversible. There is no known cure for alcoholism. One can only arrest the symptoms through abstination.

3) Like other diseases, whether phychological or physical in origin or both, it follows a specific predictable course, including symptoms, and responds to specific treatments.

The success of treatements is influenced by administration, chracterization, and consistency in following the prescription.

True alcoholism, the disease, is chronic. In other words, someone isn't sort of an alcoholic. What makes it difficult to dintinguish for society, is that there are many habitual abusers of the subtstance of alcohol who have not yet contracted the disease, and also, there are a number of alcoholics who remain undiagnosed and/or in denial of the disease. Habitual abusers are likely to contract the disease and sustain these permanent changes.

A number of research studies are currently underway in which the changes in brain function in those with alcoholism versus those who abuse alcohol are being documented.
 02 Oct 2007 01:16
by Amore01 Amore01
 Firstly, a disease is figuratively defined as "A particular quality, habit, or disposition regarded as adversely affecting a person or group of people". When most people think of a disease, they think of various infestations which cause harm to the body, or failure of certain body parts, such as the liver. However, many of these diseases are caused by the over-consumption of food or other consumables. Diabetes has a large part in how much carbohydrate is taken into the body during the life, while heart disease is associated with cholesterol. I think that alcoholism is just another disease that happens to bear the name of the over-used substance that has negative connotations and is therefore discredited.
 02 Oct 2007 01:10
by Grits32808 Grits32808
 Have you ever seen an alcoholic shake uncontrollably when he/she hasn't had enough to drink. They have to drink a certain amount just to stop the shaking. It's called maintenance. If you believe anyone chooses that as a part of daily living then you can believe that its not a disease. You might choose to have that first drink but you don't choose how you body and brain react to it.
 27 Oct 2008 13:50
by Darlene21 Darlene21
 I would consider it a disease. Recent studies have shown that it is hereditary. Not just something that sets a bad example for someone, while it is a bad example, people are predisposed to be drinkers within the family.
 02 Jul 2008 04:24
by Tiggersmom Tiggersmom
 Yes because it can be passed down in generations and usually addictions aren't passed down. Also it is usually something you can't control in cases. So it is not a choice, but rather something you have to deal with!
 07 May 2008 03:32
by Hellopeopl Hellopeopl
 The genetic and environmental predisposition to this condition besides the patients inability to control it, along with the physical retributions of it, all convince me that it is a disease.
 28 Apr 2008 19:20
by Pencil Pencil
 Yes it is a big problem when someone has a drinking problem it can led to lots of problems they need help i don't think it is a disease it is an addiction like drugs ....
 23 Apr 2008 06:39
by Lilmama1 Lilmama1
 Having worked for a 3/4 house, I know it is a disease. People who have close relatives that are alcoholics are more likely to become ones themselves, just like cardiac disease and cancers, etc. I also feel that although it is treatable, it cannot be cured. Those who battle alcoholism, do it daily!
 31 Mar 2008 04:24
by Lam3002 Lam3002
 Alchoolism is a habit and an addiction, so yes it could be a disease..... But it could be cured
 13 Oct 2007 22:26
by Des07 Des07
 Yes it is a diese a sickness,and everyone suffers from it .....and it is and addiction.
 04 Oct 2007 21:44
by Grace33 Grace33
 It is also considered a disability and you can recieve help with college tuition and vocational services with completion of a rehab facility. In hopes that you might better yourself. Read up on Carl Jung and Bill W. If you really want some insight into how devastating alcoholisim really is
 04 Oct 2007 04:27
by Darkstar Darkstar
 Yes, it is a disease. People who suffer from this serious mental illness can litterally drink themselves to death. They suffer terrible halucinations known as (dt)s, delerium tremens. They destroy their bodies as well as their minds. It also causes great stress and anxiety to loved ones who can also become seriously ill due to living with someone who developes severe behavioural problems. Because it is so common it has become the subject of jokes. It is a terrible addiction which slowly destroys the individual and his very dignity. It is a social disease, an addictive disease and creates great dis-ease for the sufferer.
 03 Oct 2007 02:51
by Padraig Padraig
 I believe that alcoholism is an addiction, which can CAUSE disease, such as liver failure, nerve damage etc. Much the same as tobacco smoking is an addiction that can cause cancer.
 02 Oct 2007 12:30
by Harka Harka
 I don't think it's a disease..I think it's an acquired addiction. A disease is usually something we have no control over, it just happens to our bodies, but we have the choice to drink or not to drink..and if we choose to, the result can be a disease such as cirrosis (sp?) of the liver..very fatal.
 02 Oct 2007 16:21
by Melissa3 Melissa3
 I do not think it is-no other addiction that I know of has been declared a disease, only alcohol. Submitted this as a debate in order to weigh the pro,s & con,s.
 02 Oct 2007 00:32
by Whhandyman Whhandyman
 It is an adddiction, a consequence from one choosing to drink alcohol.
 27 Aug 2008 22:22
by Blondiemom Blondiemom
 Alcoholism is not a disease, but it can certainly destroy you.
 07 Jun 2008 03:19
by Guest Guest
 I believe alcoholism is an addiction not a disease... It has gotten so much press and there are so many people addicted that is has reached a point where people accept it as something they can't help.

I think looking at it as a disease only enables people to give in to it presuming that they "can't help it." It is an addiction, like smoking, like heroin, pot, meth, these people all decided to do it, and continue doing it despite the consequences.

People who are alcoholics generally have other mental illnesses which lead to their excessive drinking but alcoholism itself is not by any means a disease, it makes it easier to contract diseases certainly, due to lowered inhibitions and the fact that alcohol damages your body as well.
 28 Apr 2008 22:26
by Mamacass Mamacass
 I may be posting my opinion on the wrong on e but i think it is addiction and a disease and yes if someone who drinks wants to quit they can but i also believe it is a mind thing if yu put your mind to something then you will do it so if the person is an alcoholic and they put their mind to it they will stop drinking but alcohol causes diseases but is not truly a disease it s an addiction
 27 Apr 2008 08:22
by Ladysmom Ladysmom
 Alcoholism is not a disease. I strongly disagree when people at AA are told "once an alcoholic, always an alcoholic". Plain and simple alcoholism is sin and if you choose---Jesus can set you free. That's right. He can deliver you, which means you have it no longer. You make the choice. The Bible says "Whom the Son sets free is free indeed." Thank-you Lord. That we can confess our sins to you and if we truly mean it and want to turn from our ways --you will forgive us and give us a brand new start!!
 07 Mar 2008 19:59
by Dallasgirl Dallasgirl
 I believe alcoholism is an addiction, not an illness. I can be addicted to caffeine, but that does not make me ill. The alcoholic can be free from his addiction just like any drug user. Interestingly, I never heard that being said about other drug addiction. Are they all ill? They may get ill by their abuse of substance, but that is the effect, not the cause of their addiction.
 22 Feb 2008 10:05
by Rev_eb Rev_eb
 I think its a habit and the body craves it, more than its an illness.
 07 Feb 2008 05:41
by Cabrunet Cabrunet
 If you think Alcoholism isn't a disease then you must think being addicted to medication isn't bad ether! What a world we live in
 31 Jan 2008 18:28
by Rbdaker09 Rbdaker09
 Alcoholism is not a disease any more than smoking is a disease. Both alcoholism and smoking are behavioral choices. They cause some diseases, such as cirrhosis of the liver or emphysema, but the behaviour is not a disease.
 22 Jan 2008 18:24
by Dmchatham Dmchatham
 I believe individuals make choices, constructive or destructive to themselves, so alcohol use and abuse should not be consider a disease.
 21 Jan 2008 03:38
by Lella2008 Lella2008
 No, I think it's just a habit the body gets use to like smoking.
 12 Jan 2008 20:07
by Bwtsrl Bwtsrl
 Alcoholism is not a disease it is a habit that we can control a disease is something we can't control it just happens to us like flu u can't control flu and stop it from attacking your body.we can fight alcoholism and stop it on the other hand some diseases can be cured like cancer. Cancer can sometimes be cured and when it is advanced it can't
 01 Jan 2008 08:25
by Nora575 Nora575
 No. It is not a disease. I say this because I don't think you can "cure" a disease with the stopping of a bad habit. Some people may have a predisposed weakness to alcohol due to their genetic make-up but to call a bad habit a disease is wrong and may give some people who are addicted an excuse to continue to drink ie "I have a disease, I need it I cant help it"
I say all of this because alcohol took me to a very dark place called JAIL. I quit drinking with the help of my Savior.
 19 Dec 2007 17:56
by Mablaha Mablaha
 No it is a choice to stay imprisoned to it. I know. I am only 18 and i have concured alchoholism.
 05 Dec 2007 02:09
by Nakitahime Nakitahime
 I totally do not think it is a disease.
 11 Nov 2007 23:44
by Coolest225 Coolest225
 Alcholism is not a disease. Some people take it occasionally. Some take it daily. Getting addicted to it is like a disease
 22 Oct 2007 11:52
by Skyadamani Skyadamani
 I don't believe it to be a disease. I know an alcoholic that can stop drinking to go to work, on the other hand I do know diabetics that can't stop their insulin when they go to work. A disease is uncontrolable without medicine to help, too many people I know can stop drinking and still be called an alcoholic
 02 Oct 2007 01:43
by Chatter Chatter
There Will One Day Be A Cure For All The Present Day Diseases!
Prevention Is Better Than Cure.
Bird Flu Is A Disease Created By People As A Weapon.
I Don't Believe There Is Even One Good Health Benefit To Smoking.
 
 

Ask a Question via Twitter

Send a question to @askblurtit and we will publish it online and send you a reply everytime you receive an answer.

Blurtit Store

Get T-shirts, hoodies, caps and more at the Blurtit store

Blurtit International