Home Debates The Victors Write The Textbooks.
The Victors Write The Textbooks.
For
Do You Agree With The Saying That " The Victors Write The Text Books." Or Disagree Because Society Has Too Much Access To Information Today. Please State Why You Fell So. This Is The Third Time That I've Posted This And I Hope It Won't Just Disappear Again.
by Diaflor Diaflor
 06 Apr 2008 18:42  
Against
 While there may be more than one side to a story, it is rare to see an objective characterization of the conflict, even if other information exists elsewhere. What one reads in textbooks about conflicts is most often the work of those who arose victorious from them, as seen through their lense and worldview.
 08 Apr 2008 14:41
by Amore01 Amore01
 Textbooks are written by powerful publishers with their own agendas, sometimes hidden.
 07 Apr 2008 18:34
by Guest Guest
 I am for and against. History is what we get from the witnesses or those involved in the 'Stories' we get from the past. They are written from the perspective of the writer. The guy who actually wrote something down, will become the historian of the moment. If all we have is his version, we have one eye witness account. The victors are more likely to write about their experiences than the losers. So sometimes that is very true.
 16 Apr 2008 13:09
by Pencil Pencil
 Both side write the text books, just different versions. Normally if you read both sides the truth is somewhere in between. The Victor will put a spin on it to show they were right and the cause just, the Vanquished will put the spin on that the victors fought dirty to win and how they are now 2nd class citizens in their own country (or similar). You also have to be wary these day of some of the more 'creative' versions of current or historical events told through the media, not sure who it was but the phrase "never let the truth get in the way of a good story" comes to mind, its all about selling papers, tv programmes and films now isn't it.
 08 Apr 2008 00:39
by Rostdu Rostdu
Schools Should Teach Kids In School About The War In The Middle East.
Chinghez Khan Was A Leader Not A Great Leader !
Those Who Do Not Learn From History Are DOOMED To Repeat It!
Americans Are Among The Most Charitable People In The World.
The Chicken Came Before The Egg
Humanity Gains Its Desires Only From The Exact Opposite.
Scientific Truth Which Derives From Total Reality Is More Reliable Than Religious Truth Which Derives...
Freedom Is Not Free!
Fire Breathing, Flying Dragons Exist
People Are Never Satisfied-That's What ACTUALLY Keeps The Economy Growing.
 
 

Ask a Question via Twitter

Send a question to @askblurtit and we will publish it online and send you a reply everytime you receive an answer.

Blurtit Store

Get T-shirts, hoodies, caps and more at the Blurtit store