Home Debates There Should Be A Statute Passed Whereby Consumers Can Ask For And...
There Should Be A Statute Passed Whereby Consumers Can Ask For And Evaluate A Doctor's Educational And Malpractice Records.
For
The Physician You Saw Today Might Be A Grade "C" Or "Grade A" Doc, And His Care/Competence Reflects That. Consumers Of Healthcare Services Should Be Allowed To Examine The School And Malpractice Records Of Their Physicians In Order To Make Informed Choices As To Their Care, And Such Records Would Ensure Doctors Who Are More Competent Would Be More Widely Used; Doctors Who Performed Marginally, Less Used And Eventually Cease Practice. This Would Decrease Malpractice In The Industry And Be Better For Consumers.
by Amore01 Amore01
 27 Feb 2008 23:18  
Against
 We do it for mechanics and restaurants...why not a doctor?
 06 Oct 2008 20:05
by Turnertile Turnertile
 That's not a bad idea, amore01.
 24 Jul 2008 23:22
by Jb185 Jb185
 I truly hope the doctors I have seen or my family has seen are competent. But I took my son when he was just 1 yr old, to a doctor (our regular ped. Was off) My son had full blown pneumonia, but the doctor did not detect it. He just said give him lots of tlc. Sorry doc, tlc does not cure pneumonia (my son did receive proper treatment the next day) then this same doc told me my daughter did not have strep throat- when in fact she really did. His diagnosis again was to give her lots of tlc. 2 yrs ago my husband had an episode with his heart and was handed over to a fresh from med school cardiologist who did not know one side of the heart from the other. Several months later the doc referred my husband on, but my husband died in April 2007- 10 months from the original problem. I believe that if my husband had the right doctor with the right diagnosis/treatment earlier, he'd still be alive today. He was only 37 yrs old.
 19 Jul 2008 01:07
by Blondiemom Blondiemom
 Most definitely! As robbier mentioned, there is a cost to view these databases whereas just a few years ago, anyone had the ability to view physicians' records within each state for free. The medical field is a very close-knit group who apparently take an oath to stand by each other no matter what negative aspects occur within a hospital, doctor's office, etc. This isn't right. Everyone should have the right to view a physician's "record" to determine whether or not they want to use their services. If a person wants to hire a general contractor to build a house or an office, they have the ability to view their record on the Better Business Bureau and there is no charge. It's good business sense to know who you are hiring. When you schedule a visit to a doctor or hospital, you are basically hiring their services also..
 04 Mar 2008 15:56
by Desertkid Desertkid
 I couldn't agree more. There are sites where such information is supposedly available, but there is a charge for it, and without knowing what one be getting, I would be reluctant to pay a fee for it.

Ideally the medical profession should police itself, but many doctors are not willing to be that forthcoming about their colleagues. I'm imagine the AMA is not that anxious to share negative information with the public.

I know there is a statute that has been passed recently in New York State that deals with the information mentioned above. The information is available, on request, from physicians, but I'm not too sure how that would help someone choose a physician. There is also a database that provides information on public disciplinary actions since 1990. There should be a national database like that available to the public.

There is a web site called doctorscorecard.com. An individual can score a physician but must leave a narrative (has to be approved by the site) in order for the numerical score to be recorded.

When someone's life and health is involved, he should have access to all the information needed to make an informed decision regarding the selection of a physician or a hospital.
 28 Feb 2008 04:42
by Robbier44 Robbier44
 No. The medical profession should be strict enough to enforce the license of the doctors allowed to practice medicine so they are evaluated say every six months to a year..because as you know people are vendictive and would abuse that type of system...
 28 Feb 2008 00:39
by Nomad1 Nomad1
Doctors Are More Important Than Teachers.
Illegal Immigrants Should Not Receive Free Healthcare.
Smoking Should Not Appear In Movies.
Universal Health Care Works!
Smoking Should Be Banned From Homes Containing Children Under The Age Of 18
Some Student Take Up Smoking, What Effects Can This Have On Their Lives, And Can They Do To Give Up Smoking...
If US Healthcare Insurers Were Incented To Compete On Delivering Better Care, Rather Than Competing On...
Everybody Deserves To Afford Health Care. However, Implementing Universal Health Care In The USA Would...
Should We Smoke Or Not Smoke
Girls Should Not Have The Right To Have Sex At The Age 13
Smokers Are Being Treated Like Criminals
Are Natural Supplements The Way To Go?
If Someone Has Bad Hygiene Habits And Has Odor, You Should Tell Them
Meditation Is Better Than Medication For Leading A Healthy Life.
California Needs To Have The Budget Signed.
 
 

Ask a Question via Twitter

Send a question to @askblurtit and we will publish it online and send you a reply everytime you receive an answer.

Blurtit Store

Get T-shirts, hoodies, caps and more at the Blurtit store