Home RelationshipsFamilyParenting Subscribe to RSS

Should I Hit My Child To Discipline Him Or Her?

Answer Question

7 Answers - Sort by: Date | Rating

    I think you can discipline a child without hitting them.  I never did because I don't believe in hitting anyone.
    I, personally prefer to talk to them and let them explain to me why they did what they did  and then I tell them it was wrong and I explain to them why it was wrong so they won't do it again.  And instead of hitting them, I take something of theirs that they really like for a while, depending on what they did or if they were suppose to do something they love doing, they can't do it anymore and they can't go to that place they really like, and let me tell you that it works at our house.
    I'm not saying that it works for everybody, but it does at my house.

    It takes a lot of time and patience sometimes but it's worth it and they learn at the same time.
    I don't want to teach my children to hit, so why would I hit them?
    1 1

    Carole 

    answered 3 years ago

      Physical punishment has always been a method of teaching people a lesson.  The lesson is that if you do or don't do something that the punisher says, they will use their physical strength to strike you, hurting or humiliating you, often in public situations.

      However, when a child learns right and wrong under the threat of violence, I wonder if they are actually not learning right from wrong at all.  What they are learning is to fear the violence and when that fear or reality is not present, the child has nothing to teach them right from wrong.

      The child also learns that control can be achieved in a situation by the use of physical violence against another.  This has proven to the child its effectiveness.  The more violence, the more pain, the great the control, also it teaches them that people can be controlled by the threat of violence and pain.
      0 1

      Epictetus 

      answered 3 years ago

        No I don't think hitting children ever works.

        Sometimes parents do smack their children but often regret it straight away.
        Hitting a child doesn't achieve anything positive and teaches the child to be violent too.
        1 2

        Pollyh 

        answered 3 years ago

        I have a very active 10 month old girl. I never, ever "hit" her. But, if I tell her repeated times to stop playing with the speaker wire on the floor and pull her away from the wire, and she goes right back to it within seconds, eventually, I will spank her bottom and pull her away. She will usually cry because her feelings are hurt, but only for a second. Then, she goes about the business of playing with her toys and forgets about the wire(for awhile, anyway). Needless to say, if you feel it's necessary to spank your child, I don't see a problem as long as it's not all the time, and for every time you want him or her to listen to you. Just make sure not to hurt the child...The Bible says "spare the rod, spoil the child", but I don't believe that means to hurt your child, it just means that when he or she is doing something that could potentially hurt him or her, you must instill in his or her mind that "if this is done, I will be spanked, so obviously it's not something I should be doing."
        Report
        Elle-n-eva

        Elle-n-eva

        commented 2 years ago

        I am afraid there is no research or logic to that answer Pollyh.
        By hitting I believe you to mean smacking or spanking, if that is what they learn and they act out what they learn, you would surely expect there to be fewer driveby shootings and more gang fights ending spankings.
        Spanking no more teaches violence than being sent to your room teaches false imprisonment or stopping pocket money teaches theft.
        Report
        Oldman68

        Oldman68

        commented 8 months ago

        Hitting a child is not very much good, but for keeping them in discipline, sometimes it may be required. By punishing them, they have to understand what is the mistake they have done. You are able to explain the reason to the child ie the mistake which they did.
        0 1

        Ramanandsj 

        answered 3 years ago

        Hitting children is not useful to them. If you really slow down and think about it, the logic is quite ridiculous - that somehow a child who is crying because he's frustrated and tired, or feels very angry and yells insults, will be made cheerful and obedient by having somebody hurt him. The reason hurting children inspires short-term obedience is simple: It makes kids afraid of their parents. They don't feel safe enough to reveal the fact that they are angry or sad or tired; they know that if they do their parents might snatch them up and smack them painfully. Smacking kids makes the parents feel better, but not the kids. And you'll notice that people who argue for it draw arbitrary lines between "hitting" and "spanking" and "smacking". They say that's it's necessary for kids who are particularly headstrong or hostile. Again, it sounds ridiculous to me. Do these parents really believe that one child is capable of using words but the other is so stupid and primitive they must be whacked like cavemen? Because that's what is sounds like. If a parent does anything purposefully to hurt their child - anything, including spanking, insulting or humiliating him - it is abusive. I'm sorry, but that's the end of it. The idea that if your hand lands on their bottom or their hand or not on their face it's not hitting is completely untrue. Hitting is hitting. Hitting is ABUSE. Hurting your children is ALWAYS wrong, ALWAYS harmful, and ALWAYS frightening, be it bottom or hand or face, with a palm or angry words or a belt. It teaches children that the world is frightening, hostile and untrustworthy, that they themselves are not respectable or intelligent enough to behave themselves without brute intervention, and that rage and abusiveness is a valid and ordinary way of dealing with things that make them unhappy.

        In summation? No, it is NOT okay to hit your child to discipline them. Ever.
        0 1
        Guest

        Guest 

        answered 7 months ago

          I think that hitting a child to discipline them can work.

          This is because
          1)- they know if they do it again they'll get hit.
          2)- they wont want to get hit.
          3)-if you leave them, they'll think, oh cool mum or dad wont do anything I can do what I want when I want and how I want.

          It might be painful, but it does work.
          If you do do it, remember don't overdo it as it wont help, once you think your child has received the message to stop what they were doing then stop.

          But again, if your child is a child who does what you say when you say, don't bother with hitting them, just tell them you don't like it, why you don't like it and you'd appreciate it if they stopped.
          0 2

          Cute_joy 

          answered 3 years ago

          STOP!!!!!! Breath in---- breath out---- in----out---in---out------- ok.
          Relax~~!!~~~~+!~~~~~~~ look at your child~~~~~~~ do you remember that by hitting your child will only make them feel left out.
          Just tell then "no, darling please don't do that." They will learn better that way if you just tell them. Hitting them will only cause other problems when they grow up...... Breath ~~~~~in~~~~out~~~in~~out~~~~in~~~~~~out......
          0 2

          Samoapride 

          answered 2 years ago

          I wouldn't say hitting is good, but spanking or slapping the hand (not enough to bruise, mind you) is a good way to show them you mean business and to show them that what they did was wrong. there is nothing wrong with this kind of punishment if you show yourself some "disiprin"
          Report
          Pekulior

          Pekulior

          commented 1 year ago

          Don't agree with your logic against smacking, I find it quite inclusive but do agree that having little devils means breathing becomes very very important as does counting to anything from 10 to 100000.
          Report
          Oldman68

          Oldman68

          commented 8 months ago

          More

             
             

            Ask a Question via Twitter

            Send a question to @askblurtit and we will publish it online and send you a reply everytime you receive an answer.

            Blurtit Store

            Get T-shirts, hoodies, caps and more at the Blurtit store

            Blurtit International