Denis Palczynski voted up Rooster Cogburn's answer 9/22/2015 Favorite Halloween Candy? Tootsie Roll, Dots, Caramel Apple Lollipop, Mary Jane Peanut Butter Kisses, Eyeball Gum, Now and Later, Smarties, Candy Corn, Circus Peanuts, Dum Dums? Be a tough choice between Dots and Tootsie rolls. Loved them both since I was a kid! That was in ancient times ! LOL