Nina Nina

America's election day is in 4 days!!! TIME magazine has an article on 7 ideas that could improve U.S. elections: 1. Election-day registration (is an option) 2. Automatic voter registration 3. Shorter campaign seasons 4. a "none of the above" option when voting 5. Ranked voting (rank choices, good for third-party candidates) 6. Mandatory voting 7. Weekend elections. Which do you think would work? I think all except #3 and #6. 

2

2 Answers

Didge Doo Profile
Didge Doo answered

We use a couple of those options in Australia.

I guess what they call "ranked voting" is what we call "preferential voting". In other words, if there are four or five candidates running for a particular seat (a common situation) we can vote for them in the order we prefer them. That means that we can place a despised candidate at the end with everybody ahead of him/her.

We also have mandatory voting. All adults MUST register to vote and there is a fine for anybody who doesn't vote without a good reason. It makes certain we all turn out on polling day. I doubt that it helps. Forcing somebody to vote if they're not interested in politics and the socio-economic situation prevalent at the time is like giving the vote to a small child. We might as well place the ballot paper up on the wall and throw darts at it.

Shorter campaigns are a good idea. Even on this side of the Pacific we're getting tired of hearing all the accusations and counter-accusations between the candidates -- and that's AFTER all the other candidates were eliminated. I can't imagine how frustrating that must be in the US when your news outlets would be full of it.

The rebel in me loves the idea of "none of the above" but, in reality, it's not an option. There's going to be a winner, whether we like it or not, and our vote can help to put them there. Or keep them out.

Weekend elections work just fine here. It means that the majority of people are able to vote on their day off. Doesn't help emergency services, or retail, hospitality, and tourism workers, of course.

I like the suggestions but then, I live in a place where we're used to some of them already.

KB Baldwin Profile
KB Baldwin answered

I like automatic registration.  Didge pointed out the problem with mandatory voting and I think he is spot on.  I'm not in favor of term limits.  We imposed them in California, and I (at least) don't see that they have done much good, and may actually be counterproductive.  As our election cycle is fixed by our Constitution, I don't see how we could shorten it.  Isn't like a parliamentary system where an election can be called at anytime.

Also don't see anyway at all to hold the news organizations or positions accountable for what they say.  For example, some folks reading this probably think the MSM constantly distorts the news to favor the liberal view.  Others probably think the MSM is way too weak in reporting truth, and that the Fox network wouldn't recognize truth if it jumped up and bit them on the bum. 

I like mail-in ballots.  I believe Oregon has gone for it 100%.  In California it is an option available, and more people every year take advantage of it.  Of course I live in a small county with a very well run Elections Department so even when I actuaklly went in to vote, the longest line i ever encountered was three or foru folks. 

Answer Question

Anonymous