Didge Doo

If a person proved they had reincarnated, could they reclaim ownership of property they owned in a previous life? And if, say, a corporation or a householder now occupied their land, could they charge rent?

6

6 Answers

Ray  Dart Profile
Ray Dart answered

I cannot answer your question, since (whilst I have an open mind on reincarnation) I cannot believe that past life ownership is provable.

BUT, I worked in Tel Aviv for a while.

50, 60, 70+ years ago the Palestinians who owned and lived in a lot of properties there left, presumably hoping one day to come back.

Those houses are still empty, decaying and (sortof) un-owned (unless the grandchildren of the original owners choose to return).

You don't need re-incarnation to reclaim ownership......

6 People thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
Good examples. I was also thinking of Jewish property, but that which was confiscated by Hitler's regime.

I first came up with this idea for a Tall Tales column for a suburban newspaper when I gave possession of the land on which the taxation department had built their offices. I awarded the previous owner a percentage of the taxes raised. Of course, since I was standing in for God at the time (a kind of
Yin And Yang Profile
Yin And Yang answered

It's bad enough the way families "vulture" over possessions when the still breathing are breathing! I can't imagine the fights that would go on with in families if a loved one came back to claim their property!

6 People thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
Ah, but there'd be a wicked opportunity to indulge in a bit of well-deserved schadenfreude as the unworthy heirs were stripped of their gains.

Hmm, if there were too many cases the courts might have to set aside one day a week to deal with them. It would be a "bad heir day".

(This will never happen with my will, of course. I'm planning to outlive all the kids.)
Yin And Yang
Yin And Yang commented
Bad heir day!!!!!!!! Love it! Tooooooo funny my friend!
Tom  Jackson Profile
Tom Jackson answered

Interesting.

In the movie Highlander (The film features a number of flashback scenes establishing Connor MacLeod of the Clan MacLeod's early history, and builds up to his final destiny among the last of the mysterious Immortals) Connors's final identity was Russell Edwin Nash (nom de plume) .

He maintained his assets by leaving them to the subsequent identify prior to the final "Gathering."

This would imply a quit claim deed process.

I would assume (an admitted dangerous position) that laws are some how written that ownership is terminated by death (although distribution of our assets at death is provided for).

And since death would be required (?) in order to reincarnate, I presume ownership rights would cease at that time.

(Sounds logical, but whether it meets the tests of valid logic depends on the accuracy of one's predications.)

4 People thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
Joseph Heller would swell with pride at that answer, Tom. I think you've just effectively stated Catch 22. :)
Tom  Jackson
Tom Jackson commented
Well, if we can determine that he has been reincarnated, perhaps we could seek his opinion as well.
Bikergirl Anonymous
Well, I suppose if one believed in reincarnation, they could plausibly request (in their last will and testiment) that their belongings be kept in a vault somewhere, so when they 'came back' and matured to a legal age that they could claim it again. They just have to make sure they leave very specific instructions about where they leave the key to that big'ol vault.
Ancient One Profile
Ancient One answered

I have pondered your question for a day or so. What little I know of the intricate aspects of reincarnation bring me to believe, unless you made some sort of private arrangements beforehand  you are out of luck. What once beloned to you in a prior life follows it's destiney upon your death.

3 People thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
Sad, but true, Ancient. Life will be a lot less complicated if we stick to one lifetime for each person, I guess. All I really have to leave is my house and it's been well lived-in for more than 50 years. Might be better to start again -- if I ever got the chance, of course.
Jann Nikka Profile
Jann Nikka answered

Your claim to land does with you. You can not and should not be able to reclaim anything, you died rights died.

Otherwise, no one else assuming reincarnation is even possible you could continue to come back over and over and over again for eternity and claim the same land,  inheritance, money and whatever else never relinquishing "your" right to someone else.

When would eternal ownship start?

2 People thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
If it ever happens, Jan, I'm gonna have to hope the judge sees it from a different point of view. Maybe my lawyer will be able to find a loophole. :)
Bikergirl Anonymous Profile

Hypothetically speaking .. No you would not be able  to reclaim assets of any kind .. Because at death your assets are handed down to others .. Ending your "ownership". 

1 Person thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
As if dying isn't bad enough, I lose all my rights as well. Good grief, even the ancient Egyptians were kinder than that. If I'd died way back then all my goodies would have been buried along with me, including my slaves. :)
Bikergirl Anonymous
Yea .. like that stuff is gonna do you any good where YOU are going!
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
Well, yeah, I guess. What was it Mark Twain said? Heaven for climate; Hell for company. >:-)

Answer Question

Anonymous