Didge Doo

How do we explain child prodigies? Is their talent inherited genetically? Are they reincarnations who brought their talent with them? Have they been possessed by the spirit of a dead genius? Or is there really a very simple explanation?

3

3 Answers

Maurice Korvo Profile
Maurice Korvo answered

I think it is just the way their minds are set up (hard wiring) which makes some things obvious to them. In music, they seem to anticipate the notes that would sound good in combinations. In math, they are, I believe, more logical than the rest of us.  It could be that there are many people like this, but only some are given the opportunity to excel.

PJ Stein Profile
PJ Stein answered

I saw a how some years ago that explained it is because some of their parents started teaching them at an extremely young age. I have read that even though an infant's dexterity is still developing their minds are absorbing all the information. As they develop physically the you can see the information surfacing. They showed someone who used flash cards for math as they changed their diaper. Another that would play language tapes. Another that started playing musical scales.

3 People thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
A Hungarian psychologist named Polgar set out to teach his young daughters how to play chess. The lessons continued through their childhood and they became three of the strongest women in the world. One, Judit, was even a candidate for the men's world championship -- and that was before there were many women grandmasters.

I was fortunate to play Susan Polgar when she visited Sydney. She played 20 of us at the same time and won all 20 games. It was like playing chess with a boa constrictor.

Thanks for the answer.
Walt O'Reagun Profile
Walt O'Reagun answered

Both Gator and Korvo are correct.

The brain is like any other part of the body ... As you exercise it, it develops more capacity for exercise.

I believe a lot of prodigies were also what we know call "autistic", to some degree.

3 People thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
It'd be interesting to understand that aspect of autism. some years ago a Swedish R&D company actually showed preference for employees who had Asperger's. thanks, Walt.
PJ Stein
PJ Stein commented
I think as we learn more about autistic people we will find many of them are brilliant but have trouble communicating. I read an article 2-3 years ago about a family who had a severely autistic daughter. They tried a special school and other group settings but they never worked out. So they hired a special therapist to work with her at home.

The therapist would wrote notes on a laptop and would talk to the girl as she did so. One day the therapist left the laptop on while she went to do something in another room. When she came back the girl who was around the age of 12, was typing on the computer. Now mind you she had never been taught to do so. When the therapist looked at what she typed it said she hurt. The therapist asked her if she hurt an the girl nodded.

They got the girl her own computer so she could communicate. They were searching a way to treat her pain. They learned she was often so frustrated because she was always in pain.

I suspect as we learn more we will find more cases that just because they have trouble communicating doesn't mean they are diminished.

Or even looking at savant syndrome, which used to be called idiot savant. They will find one thing we can understand and do it well, but that they are not idiots, just not like us and can't find a way to communicate with us on our level.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
Idiot savant, even in a pre-PC era, was an exceptionally unenlightened term. It was one I was pleased to see drop out of use. We still have a long way to go with autism but we're making progress.

Answer Question

Anonymous